Men of Respect V.S Macbeth Essay - 738 Words

Compare and Contrast Essay In 1991, William Shakespeares great play Macbeth was re-created into a modern day version titled Men of Respect. Was the plays textual fidelity lost in transition during the making of the film, or did the film show total loyalty and devotion to the text and the feelings of the play? A closer examination of the characters/lines, classification between good and evil, and the use of light and dark will compare the many differences and similarities between William Shakespeares Macbeth and William Reillys Men of Respect. Set in present day New York (present as in 1991), the various warring kingdoms of the play become organized crime factions in the film, King Duncan becoming†¦show more content†¦2 31-32). This symbolizes the great guilt that Macbeth feels. He has alienated himself from God, even though this was the time he needed to blessed the most by God. This is the start of Macbeths great decent into insanity and evil. In William Reillys version of this scene ( which takes place in what seems to be a dark sewer) the lines remain very similar to Shakespeares, with only a very few amount of words changed, still allowing the audience to be captured by Macbeths true feelings In Macbeth, Shakespeare uses light and dark to bring out the ideas of good and understanding, and to show the audience the evil and hiding that takes place during the play. Just like Shakespeare, Reilly used light and dark to distinguish between the change of character in Macbeth. Unlike Shakespeare, Reilly also used the colour red in many of his scenes. Red demonstrated evil, and whenever red was used, it was clear that death was near. For instance, just before Mickey killed Charlie, they showed a quick glimpse of Ruthie Bataglia. The light that shown on her face was blood red. The theme of light and dark in Macbeth is portrayed with the candles, the shadows, the sun, and the witches. From its supernatural opening to its gruesome climax, ‘Macbeth is the Shakespeare play that reads most like a film script. DanielShow MoreRelatedA Character s Personality And Stereotypes During The Elizabethan Time Period1962 Words   |  8 PagesShakespeare highlights various themes relating to a character’s personality and stereotypes during the elizabethan time period. During Macbeth, Shakespeare extends the common theme by suggesting that many characters may be portrayed in a way that is not the reality of that character’s true personality. Many characters are deceiving and may not reveal their inner-self due to the predicted downfall of their image in society. This is the primary way that the other characters view others because theyRead MoreA Character s Personality And Stereotypes During The Elizabethan Time Period1962 Words   |  8 PagesShakespeare highlights various themes relating to a character’s personality and stereotypes during the eliza bethan time period. During Macbeth, Shakespeare extends the common theme by suggesting that many characters may be portrayed in a way that is not the reality of that character’s true personality. Many characters are deceiving and may not reveal their inner-self due to the predicted downfall of their image in society. This is the primary way that the other characters view others because theyRead MoreHM Case Study16624 Words   |  67 PagesStudies, a Practical Guide, the authors Ghauri, P. and Grohaug, K also mention two ways to conduct a research. These are qualitative method and quantitative method respectively and the comparison between them is given below: Table 1 Qualitative Methods V.S. Quantitative Methods Source: Ghauri and Grohaug, 2002, p.86 9 In some literature about research methods, it is often thought that structured and quantitative methods are more scientific and therefore better. However, on this book, the authors state